|
Advertising vs. Public
Relations: Which Is More Profitable?
Studies have shown that most sales are made only after
frequent exposures to a product or service through various media. This
'media' can run the gambit from nontraditional media concepts like
networking groups, to media that is more conventional like radio, TV,
and direct mail.
In much of the media, you will have the choice of using
that medium for the purpose of advertising, as a public relations
vehicle, or for both.
Advertising usually 'hooks' more entrepreneurs because
of its high visibility. Not only do you see hundreds of ads day in and
day out (2700 a day according to Jay Conrad Levinsons's Guerrilla
Marketing) but ad reps are probably calling on you from a variety of
media touting the benefits of advertising in their particular medium.
Making the right media selection, and developing the right market
appeal, can make an ad campaign very profitable. But as we've said
earlier, advertising can be tricky -- not to mention expensive.
Public relations on the other hand can cost little or
nothing. Articles written about you are typically more credible than
ads, and they can get you far more mileage if you're on a tight budget.
Advertising is just one way to communicate with your
marketplace. But all your networking, public relations mentions, feature
articles, etc. work together with your advertising to build up the
frequency level necessary to get your prospects and customers to buy.
Advertising and public relations, properly placed, can
build credibility for your organization, develop product awareness,
reach more prospects than direct sales methods, generate leads, and
reduce your sales costs.
It’s not possible to pin down an exact return on
investment (ROI) a business can expect from its marketing communications
investment, however, as it will vary depending upon the product, the
appeal, market conditions, and many other factors.
But as Westinghouse and many other organizations have
discovered, there is a direct relationship between advertising
expenditures and returns that they can pinpoint by studying their
results. The Westinghouse study indicates that with a significant amount
of advertising at work for their products, the sales dollar-per-dollar
of advertising ran from a high of $154 to a low of $9. WalMart on the
other hand, has a much higher return on investment, usually over $1,000
for every dollar invested in advertising particular campaigns.
Although advertising can play a vital role in reaching
your markets, as I've said before, it is not the only means by which
your company's message is conveyed. Impressions may come from signs,
displays, editorial press coverage, seminar appearances, radio
interviews, networking, and a host of other methods.
Unlike advertising, public relations activities offer a
variety of things you can do to get exposure, make impressions, and get
leads -- that don't cost much or any money.
Public relations is a tremendous asset for developing
market awareness, educating the market, providing positive information
about your products and services, and generating response from the
target market.
It’s a powerful medium only used by 12%-15% of the
businesses that could profit from PR.
A recent study indicated that 45 percent of all the
material reported by news media starts from a press release.
Journalists develop their impression of your products
and organization through your press materials and conferences. In some
regards, building credibility and visibility with the press takes much
the same course as advertising. Frequent contact, newsworthy items (not
fluff), and maintaining a professional appearance in your releases are
very important in creating a good, lasting impression.
Even if your releases are not published (and many won’t
be), press releases and other PR efforts will help you begin to build
the credibility necessary for a publication or journalist to recognize
you at a later date.
Patience is definitely a virtue when it comes to press
relations. It sometimes takes months or years to become recognized
enough to have a major story published. In other cases, companies got
great coverage early on in their efforts. Whatever happens in your
situation, you will be well-rewarded by sticking with your PR program.
A high-tech firm had the good fortune to publish an
eight-page feature article focusing on the unique aspects of the
telecommunication environment they address. Within days of publication
they were inundated with phone inquiries, several of which resulted in
sales to the tune of $500,000-plus! Although there was some cost
incurred for the writer and accompanying artwork, these costs were
minimal compared to advertising expenditures that would have been
necessary to obtain the same results.
The cost of using PR is minimal. Most of this work can
be done in-house by building a well-targeted media mailing list and
developing some simple writing skills for press releases and feature
articles. Pick up a copy of Power Marketing for Small Business
for the 'how-to's' of writing press releases.
Public relations should be an integral part of your
marketing strategy to obtain optimal performance from your long range
plan. And it’s probably the least expensive way to begin developing
the long-term relationships necessary to achieve success.
What’s Involved in a Public Relations Program?
Public relations programs can be multifaceted, utilizing
any or all of the following:
Feature articles (4 to 10 double-spaced, pages) on
your company, products, technology, or method of doing business.
News items (1/2 to 2 pages) about any of the above.
These may include announcements of new management, new products, or
other newsworthy topics.
Press conferences announcing major newsworthy events
of interest to your public(s).
Sponsorships of athletic teams, charitable
organizations, TV or radio broadcasts, special events, scholarships,
etc.
Typically, these programs may have little cost
associated with them, especially as compared to advertising programs.
But, they can generate widespread awareness about your organization and
products, educate your market, and boost sales.
Who Are Your Publics?
When planning your public relations program, it is
important to consider all of your publics. Do you have stakeholders,
customers, prospects, or key industry executives you must keep informed?
Would you like your prospects to know about events occurring in your
organization? How about your staff? Shouldn’t they be included in the
information flow as well?
The most frequently required program is one that keeps
industry luminaries, prospects, and customers informed of your
activities. To accommodate these publics, you may include newspapers,
television stations, magazines (possibly both trade and consumer
publications), and trade associations. Basically, any media that reaches
your target audience, and specifically your target market, should be
included on your media list. And please, include the smaller local or
regional media if they're appropriate. They’re usually hungry for good
stories and may give you far more coverage than the mainstream media.
Table of Contents
l Next - Chapter 3: Phase 2 of the
Sales Process: The Inquiry
|
Companies, large and
small, that use public relations regularly, find their sales increase
typically from 10 to 15 percent.
One press release can be a
real workhorse. It can inform the media as well as your key customers,
prospects, management team, and influentials within your target market.
As a speaker at a trade
show and conference I took the opportunity to sit in on a presentation
by the editor of the local Business Journal. His topic, "Getting
Media Coverage."
The first thing he did was
to set down a stack of press releases (all unfolded) about 18"
high. "These," he informed his audience, "are the press
releases I've received this week." He then carefully selected
approximately the top inch or inch and a half. "These," he
continued, "are the press releases that contain information that
will be of interest to our readers."
His caution, "target
the media based on their audience, not just because they exist. I get so
much that is inappropriate for our readers, that when I do get a
legitimate story for our audience from one of these companies who I
recognize that usually sends 'junk', it just gets trashed."
A friend, a local real
estate broker, came to me with a story I've heard many times over the
years. "I've just started my business, I don't have any money, how
can I market myself?"
I invited her to help me
work on a press release announcing the opening of her real estate
brokerage. We sent a one page press release to the local newspapers (2
to be exact). The smaller of two local newspapers ran the release
verbatim. The larger of the two newspapers phoned her and conducted a
one-hour phone interview which resulted in a full tabloid page of
coverage in their paper.
The phone was ringing, and
she couldn't have been happier.
A couple of weeks later,
she started receiving calls from outside her local market. Upon calling
the larger newspaper, we found that the story had been syndicated to
several other Northwestern papers which resulted in inquiries coming in
for weeks from buyers who wanted her services.
How’s that for results on
a 58-cent PR campaign?!
Plan a whole
"campaign" at once. This may include public relations,
networking, ads, etc. Commit to a minimum six month plan (preferably one
year) with as high a frequency of contact with the same individuals
within your target market as possible. Put it in writing and DO IT!!!
"I'm calling from Brussels and I'd like to place
an order" says a woman with a thick English accent early one
morning. It was my first call of the day and I guess my brain cells
hadn't kicked in or something because my response was something really
intelligent like "is that in Kansas?"
"No mam," says the formal voice, we're in
"Belgium."
I was finally waking up and took down her order
information. She learned about my book through a professional magazine
(PR) that her husband picked up on a business trip to the US.
"Would you like to use Mastercard, Visa, or
American Express" I asked after I had her order information.
"Oh, we don't bother with such things here,"
she said. "If you'll just give me your bank account number I'll
wire the funds to you directly into your account." Wow, cool!
|